Is The BMW 8-Series Gran Coupe Better With A V8 Petrol Or An I6 Diesel?

Is The BMW 8-Series Gran Coupe Better With A V8 Petrol Or An I6 Diesel?

We’ve swapped a BMW 840d GC for an M850i. But which one is the better car?

BMW - Is The BMW 8-Series Gran Coupe Better With A V8 Petrol Or An I6 Diesel? - Blog

A little over a year ago, I stuck my neck out to suggest that the BMW 8-series works better with a diesel inline-six than a petrol V8. Today, I’d once again like to get into the 8er diesel vs petrol debate, but don’t panic – this isn’t a case of Morpheus-troubling deja vu.

This time, it’s the 8-series Gran Coupe we’re talking about, rather than the shorter two-door version of the 8. Plus, the personal context isn’t quite the same. I’ve spent about five months with an 840d GC (admittedly, it didn’t move a whole lot for a month and a half of that), and have since switched to an M850i GC.

BMW - Is The BMW 8-Series Gran Coupe Better With A V8 Petrol Or An I6 Diesel? - Blog

After first making the swap, I wasn’t sure it felt much quicker, despite the M850i having an additional ~200bhp to play with. A total of 513bhp, to be exact. The 840d being damn near as torquey as its V8 sibling will be part of that; it churns out 502lb ft, versus the M850’s 553lb ft.

Get out of the similarly punchy mid-range and venture into the top end, however, and the petrol engine’s extra potency becomes clear. It’s an absurdly quick car for something weighing around two tonnes, hitting 0-62mph in 3.9 seconds, a drop of just two tenths relative to the lighter coupe.

BMW - Is The BMW 8-Series Gran Coupe Better With A V8 Petrol Or An I6 Diesel? - Blog

The delivery is addictive. Turbo lag is barely perceptible, and the howling noise is more akin to a chunk of modern eight-cylinder Americana than something hailing from Munich. In terms of handling, the setup doesn’t differ a whole lot from the diesel; it still does a commendable job of feeling smaller and lighter than it actually is (all-wheel steering certainly helps in this regard), even if it’s not entirely able to mask the bulk.

The extra thrust of the V8 taxes the all-wheel drive system more, though, making it easier to get some movement from the rear axle. Factor in the added venom with which it can spit you out of a corner, and you have a very different driving experience.

BMW - Is The BMW 8-Series Gran Coupe Better With A V8 Petrol Or An I6 Diesel? - Blog

However, it comes down to the same issue we had with the M850i coupe; the shouty, responsive V8 seems at odds with the rest of the package. BMW clearly wants this to be a grand tourer, and that desire is merely amplified with the more practical Gran Coupe and its stretched wheelbase/extra doors.

On the GT front, it doesn’t quite hit the mark, either. The 8er is a fine cruiser whatever engine you stick in it, but it’s a long way from Mercedes S-Class coupe levels of waft, plushness and refinement.

BMW - Is The BMW 8-Series Gran Coupe Better With A V8 Petrol Or An I6 Diesel? - Blog

The biggest issue for the M850i – in all three of its body styles – is the price. In Gran Coupe form it’s £99,991 before you’ve started adding options, putting it in range of the £107k Porsche Panamera GTS, which is a far sportier feeling car that’s no less comfortable.

Coming in at a much more reasonable £72,155, the 840d is far easier to recommend. So too is the similarly priced 840i which, with its lighter inline-six petrol engine, is the nimblest GC of the lot.

BMW - Is The BMW 8-Series Gran Coupe Better With A V8 Petrol Or An I6 Diesel? - Blog

And yet, the M850i GC is the one I’m drawn to most. Of all the 8ers I’ve sampled – M8 Competition included – it’s the one that provides the best all-round enjoyment. It makes little sense and there are plenty of better ways to spend your money, but it might just be my favourite thing that BMW makes right now.




Rims, Mag Wheels & Tyres Online | Rims, Wheels & Tyre Dealer Australia by Shop your Wheels & Tyres Today

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *